Thursday, December 4, 2014

A bittersweet farewell...

It’s the end of an era in Baltimore. The O’s bade farewell to their longest tenured player, as Nick Markakis signed a four-year, $44M contract with the Atlanta Braves.

Truthfully, I’m not surprised. After the Braves traded Jason Heyward, they needed a leadoff hitter and a RF. Markakis, a Georgia boy, made perfect sense for them.

While I’m not surprised, I am disappointed. If there was one guy on the Orioles – and maybe in all of baseball – that I thought could be a career-guy with one team, it was Nick.

The Orioles said farewell to their longest tenured player, as
Nick Markakis signed a 4 year/$44M deal with the Braves.
To me, Nick Markakis was (and still is) the perfect role model. A gritty player who works hard, keeps his mouth shut and performs consistently on the field. You always knew what you were going to get and he set a great example for his teammates and young fans alike. I think his presence in Baltimore will be greatly missed – not just on the field, but in the clubhouse and the community.

With that being said, I wholly trust Dan Duquette. He’s earned that much over the last 3 seasons from Orioles fans. I’m sure there will be overreactions, people wanting to burn DD and Angelos in effigy, but let’s allow things to play out. I’m far more concerned with how the team looks in March than in December. Dan signed Nelson Cruz and Ubaldo Jimenez last season after many had already declared the off-season (and regular season for that matter) over in Baltimore.

Let’s take a look at the pros and cons of what this means for the Orioles going forward:

Pros
1.      While I don’t necessarily agree with it, the sense is the O’s were nervous about giving Nick a 4th year (his age 35 season) due to concerns over an issue with his neck. While Nick doesn’t have a skill set that should decline by then, he also isn’t a guy who tears the cover off the ball and it was suspected that his neck troubles cost him his power the last few seasons, despite his durability. This stings more so because of who Nick is and what he means to Baltimore – as a player, he’s replaceable. Sorry folks, but it’s the truth.

2.       A spot is now open. I’m guessing Dan has a deal on the burner that we don’t know about, that will allow all of this to come into focus. Whether it’s a trade for a Dodgers OF, signing Melky Cabrera, or something else, I trust DD to fill the gap.

3.       It frees up a spot for a young player to get some work with the team. I don’t know how high the organization is on the likes of Daniel Alvarez and Mike Yastrzemski, but this should provide some opportunities for them in the next season or two, if they show they can get it done.

Cons
1.       A huge hole in the locker room, in RF and in the community. Markakis was a soft-spoken, but great leader, and did a lot of charitable work in Baltimore. That is why this hurts for O’s fans right now – and it should. It will take some time to heal from this, regardless of who Dan slots into RF next season.

2.       Who’s up? It’s great if DD does have something on the go, but after letting Cruz walk (and justifiably so), he better come through or we’re looking at the likes of Alejandro De Aza and David Lough in the corner OF spots come next season. That is not the least bit inspiring.

3.       The O’s front office already has a dicey reputation with the fans and this won’t help. A front office should never make decisions just to win favour with the fans, but they also need to be in tune with how upset this is going to make fans (and I’m sure other Orioles players). While I don’t blame them for this situation, I think many will – so they are going to have to do a little damage control.

The biggest thing I want to preach right now, if I may, is patience. I know people will be sad, disappointed and frustrated, and I understand that. But let’s add rational to the list. From a baseball sense, this move has some logic to it and is not going to kill the Orioles chances of competing. I’ve already heard people turn on Markakis and talk about burning his merchandise, and I’ve heard people blast the front office. Most likely it’s somewhere in the middle. I’m sure the front office could have pushed harder, but Nick could have as well. Many get the sense Nick wanted to play closer to home, and I’m fine with that. I feel like in the end, this was a mutual split and there’s no reason to hate either side for it.

I will miss Nick in Baltimore, but the Orioles will be just fine. After all, the Cardinals have managed okay without that Pujols guy.

--Christopher Mills, @cjmills82